
Forever Grey
A Silence Like Eternity
self-released
LA’s Forever Grey have been working in an overcast and gloomy shade since, well, not literally forever, but over a decade and thus for a number of years before darkwave became the de facto dark sound du jour. Whether intentionally or not, 2022 LP Sympathy Garden featured some softening of the duo’s unremittingly bleak and monochrome aesthetic which brought them slightly closer to the dreamy and melodic style of guitar-driven darkwave which the likes of Twin Tribes and countless imitators have been plying. In some respects, that trend continues with latest LP A Silence Like Eternity.
Those new to Forever Grey will likely be struck by the severity and minimalism of their sound, even in comparison to other acts who’ve arrived in similar territory via stern post-punk like Fearing. Tracks like “Self Termination” are built around the contrast between the clean and almost antiseptic procession of bass and keys, and the low mutter of Kevin Czarnik’s voice which, despite its indiscernibility, has a resonance and depth which remains one of the band’s trademarks.
When a more melodic sensibility makes its way into A Silence Like Eternity, though, the distinction earned by Forever Grey’s more strident work diminishes. The chiming guitar and vocals from Anna Schmidt’s “Mount Everest” border on bright (or at least upon contemporary shoegaze encroachments into darkwave) and bleed into a more generalized milieu, while “Accidental Caller” uses a simple interplay between 16th note synth programming and dreamy pads to create an approachable but familiar darkwave nodder. On “I’ll Still Be Here” an easy-going, almost neo-folk strum is again framed by Czarnik’s evocative vocals and ends up connoting an alternate history in which the band cleaved to the path hewn by a number of Projekt acts.
Speaking as a long-time listener, A Silence Like Eternity doesn’t feel appreciably better or worse than Alabaster Chamber or Sympathy Garden in and of itself. The subtle ways in which “Secret Boxes” tucks synth and guitar harmonies into the corners of its cold and clean frame speak to the minimalist artistry Forever Grey have always had. A Silence Like Eternity might well be the result of a creative desire to get off the wholly bleak track on which they’ve been running for a while, but the tradeoff is that they’ve shifted into a busier corridor.